Question of the week...
It is up to you to do a Kickstarter campaign for your favorite book!
Who are you casting for the main characters?
First, I'd have to define and choose my favorite book ... Never an easy task!
By writing this blog, each year, I discover new authors and new books. So, to pick just one...Tsss...Impossible!
But to answer this question... This year, I would have chosen "The fault in our stars" by John Green. But the movie has already started to be filmed. And the casting is already picked. Is it the same one I would have chosen ? Probably not. Will it be an amazing adaptation? I can only cross my fingers.
I'm always dissapointed by a book adapted to a movie. Even when the movies are good like for "Harry Potter" or "Lords of the Ring". The reader in me will find something missing.
And when the adaptation sucks like for the first episode of "Twilight" (sorry for the Paterson's and Stewar's fans) or is not at the level of the book like for "Hunger Games" or "Beautiful Creatures", I'm having trouble to be delighted.
Again, it's only me opinion and maybe be you were perfectly happy with these movies. It's a question of art, beauty and subjectivity...
But, it makes me sad because I know that some spectactors will never read the book and just have this edulcorated version of something that was amazing while turning the pages.
So, I'm a bit anxious about watching"The Mortal Instrument." Have you enjoyed it ?
And I hope I will not be disappointed by "Divergent."
By writing this blog, each year, I discover new authors and new books. So, to pick just one...Tsss...Impossible!
But to answer this question... This year, I would have chosen "The fault in our stars" by John Green. But the movie has already started to be filmed. And the casting is already picked. Is it the same one I would have chosen ? Probably not. Will it be an amazing adaptation? I can only cross my fingers.
I'm always dissapointed by a book adapted to a movie. Even when the movies are good like for "Harry Potter" or "Lords of the Ring". The reader in me will find something missing.
And when the adaptation sucks like for the first episode of "Twilight" (sorry for the Paterson's and Stewar's fans) or is not at the level of the book like for "Hunger Games" or "Beautiful Creatures", I'm having trouble to be delighted.
Again, it's only me opinion and maybe be you were perfectly happy with these movies. It's a question of art, beauty and subjectivity...
But, it makes me sad because I know that some spectactors will never read the book and just have this edulcorated version of something that was amazing while turning the pages.
So, I'm a bit anxious about watching"The Mortal Instrument." Have you enjoyed it ?
And I hope I will not be disappointed by "Divergent."
Blog Hop...How does this work?
First you leave your name here on this post, (using the linky tools — keep scrolling!) then you create a post on your own blog that links back to this post (easiest way is to just grab the code under the #FF picture and put it in your post) and then you visit as many blogs as you can and tell them “hi” in their comments (on the post that has the #FF image).You follow them, they follow you. Win. Win. Just make sure to follow back if someone follows you! What sets this Hop apart from others, is our Feature. Each week we will showcase a Featured Blogger, from all different genres and areas. Who is our Feature today?
Find out below. Just remember it is required, if you participate, to follow our Features and you must follow the hosts (Parajunkee's View & Alison Can Read) as a courtesy. How do you follow someone? Well, if you have a preference, state it in your #FF post. A lot of blogs are transitioning to WordPress in which they do not have the luxury of GFC, so an RSS subscription is appreciated or if you choose an email subscription. If you don’t have GFC please state in your post how you would like to be followed.
I agree with you Lucie. I'm always disappointed when a movie based on a book turned out not like what I imagined it to be. The TMI movie left me with mixed feelings. I know so many fans of the book love it but I watch it with some friends who haven't read the book and they were confused as hell as to what is going on and I have to agree with them.
ReplyDeleteI'm curious so I can't not stay away from a movie based on a book I've liked. But The first Twilight was...not for me!
DeleteThanks for stopping by Primrose!
Lucie
It's a pity you didn't find the film adaptations of so many YA books satisfying. I quite enjoyed the Twilight and Hunger Games adaptation. I didn't really like The Fault in Our Stars so I probably won't see the film.
ReplyDeleteNew follower! Following you on Bloglovin'!
Hi Moonlightlibrary,
DeleteIt's fortunate that people have contrary and different opinions, it is what makes the discussions interesting.
Lucie
the fault in our stars is one of my favourite books too! I loved the TMI movie but it didn't go into much detail about the storyline, it was still great! new follower :)
ReplyDeleteCrim Reviews
Hi Jessica,
DeleteHope "The Fault in our stars" will be good beacuse I totally agree the book was awesome!
Will have to watch the TMI soom to make my opinion.
Lucie
I'm actually not that harsh on movies. I love LOTR, The hobbit, I liked Harry Potter and THG was about as good as the book. I quite liked Beautiful creatures, but I haven't read the book yet. I think it's always important to see them as two separate things. That makes it so much more enjoyable :D
ReplyDeleteFF - Mel@thedailyprophecy.
Hi Mel,
DeleteSure, I always know that it will be an adaptation and you can not descripe the book point by point. But sometimes the outcome, the cast will harm the story and that too sad.
Lucie
I watched The Mortal Instruments and I was HIGHLY disappointed. So many people said they liked it, but it is SOOOOOOO different from the book that I was mad the whole movie. It was the first movie I have ever watched that I was ready to get up and leave. I stayed just hoping it would get better but it didn't. So if you pick apart movies based on books, definitely stay away from it! I wish I did!
ReplyDeleteNew Follower!
Here my FF
Amber @Paradise of Pages
Hi Amber,
DeleteI've watched the trailer and I was hoping to have a good surprise. Will have to watch it soon. Will see...
Lucie
I absolutely agree about movie adaptations. I always find something missing or something I would have changed. And I definitely agree with you about Twilight, that was a big disappointment for me. Thanks for stopping by my blog and I am now a new follower.
ReplyDelete~April @ Once Upon a Coffin
You have good point,honestly :)
ReplyDeleteNew Follower via gfc.
http://bookerlikeahooker.blogspot.com/2013/09/feature-and-follow-5.html
You have a good point!! I was so mad with Beautiful Creatures, and they had an amazing cast! But they changed way too much of the story and the acting was horrible. I watched Mortal Instruments and I liked it. So it's a hit or miss with the movies. Thank you for stopping by my blog and I'm following you now on Bloglovin!
ReplyDeleteKathy
http://mynookbooksnmore.blogspot.com/
Movies are never as good as the books. That's so true. I am looking forward to the Fault In Our Stars movie. John Green is getting a lot of say in what happens, so that's promising.
ReplyDeleteNew bloglovin' follower
Kim @ YA Asylum
I've watched Mortal Instruments and I don't like it :|
ReplyDeleteThat was my first time watching the movie before reading the book. That movie is not good in general.
new gfc follower